Search

Why are we so obsessed with engagement survey response rates?

I’m working with an organisation at the moment that’s putting an extraordinary amount of time into getting people to complete its engagement survey – sound familiar??

We’re talking weekly reports on response rates, meetings with internal comms and other teams to work out how to get them up. Updates for stakeholders on how many people in their teams have responded. And then there’s the painstaking work of getting the reporting hierarchies right so the right managers get the right reports.

I can see why every one of those tasks is on someone’s list. Put them all together, though, and I keep coming back to the same question. What would happen if we put as much effort into improving people’s experience of work as we put into getting them to fill in the survey?

What happens after the survey closes?

There’s a collective sigh of relief when the survey closes. Then come the weeks, sometimes months, of crunching the numbers, preparing reports and presenting them to different groups. By the time some teams sit down to talk about what they’ve heard, the people who gave the feedback have moved on to the next thing they’re dealing with at work.

And which issues get attention? Often, it’s whatever scored lowest. If the survey uses a standard set of questions, those questions have already shaped what people can tell us. A low score can be worth exploring. It takes a conversation with employees to find out whether it’s something they’d prioritise and what would actually make a difference.

At some point there might be a ‘you said, we did’ update. Then we do it all again. And how often do people tell us that the thing they raised last year is still getting in their way….!

The cost of all this goes well beyond the survey platform or provider. Think of the hours spent checking who reports to whom, chasing responses and explaining why one team’s score has gone down. Those hours are rarely visible in the survey budget. And when you ask what’s been set aside for the work that follows, the answer is often very little.

Why are we still doing it this way?

I’ve been banging on about this for years! I think part of the answer is that a survey gives us a sense of control over something organisations struggle to solve. We can put a date in the diary. We can set a participation target. We can take a dashboard to the board. The work of understanding why people are having a difficult time and changing the conditions they work in is harder to schedule and harder to predict.

This is one of the reasons we’ve been talking about People First by Design at People Lab. We know a lot about what helps people do their best work, but that knowledge can struggle to make its way into the practices we use every year. If we were designing employee listening today, would we put this much of our time, money and attention into one big look in the rear-view mirror?

What would it take to look ahead?

AI will absolutely change what’s possible here. I’m interested in how it can help us notice sooner when a team is coming under pressure or when we’re starting to see signs that we might lose people.

Imagine picking up a pattern in what a team is saying about workload alongside a rise in overtime. That gives you a reason to talk with the team now. They might tell you that three different parts of the business ask for the same information every week, in three different formats. You could agree to drop one of those requests for a fortnight and see whether it frees up time. By next year’s survey, you could already know whether you’d made a difference.

That future depends on people knowing how their feedback and data are used. It also depends on treating an early signal as a reason to ask better questions. The people doing the work will often tell you something the data alone couldn’t.

Start by asking what good looks like

At People Lab, we use our Best Experience tool to ask people to tell us about a time when work was at its best for them. What were they doing? What was happening around them? What made that experience possible?

Their stories give us a much more specific idea of the experience we want to create. From there, we can ask how often people have that experience now, who finds it harder to come by, and what we could change with the people who do the work. We can use what we learn to decide what to pay attention to and where to act early.

If you’ve got another survey on the calendar, try asking two questions before it goes live. What time and money have we set aside to act on what we hear? And when will the people we’re asking for feedback get a say in what happens next?

@Emma

More Stories You May Like...